May 19, 2013

Dan Gilbert Bar Mitzvah Fracas Update

Dan GilbertCavaliers owner Dan Gilbert is known in this town as a guy who will do anything to make sure his organization is at the top of the NBA in all aspects of the game, not just with the product he puts on the floor (though his Cavs are sporting the best record in the NBA). When is comes to public relations, Gilbert has rarely made any sort of negative waves over the last four years.

The first “slip-up” if you want to call it that, came on the night of March 21st, when at a bar mitzvah at the posh Townsend Hotel in suburban Detroit (Birmingham, MI), a physical altercation took place in front of the eyes of 300 people between Gilbert and former business associate David Hall, who worked under Gilbert as the Vice President of Rock Financial, a part of the Quicken Loans family.

Reports had the two men nose to nose screaming at each other before things got physical. It wasn’t immediately known who started the altercation and how things escalated to a physical nature, but today, Gilbert’s lawyer places the blame on an “intoxicated” Hall. It’s turned into a he said-he said situation with both sides pointing fingers.

Jeffrey Morganroth, who represents the Cavaliers owner, claims an unnamed lawyer of Hall’s called him last week and threatened to go public about the fight if Gilbert didn’t buy Hall out some of his investments in Gilbert’s companies.

“There was a very minor confrontation and Dan Gilbert defended himself,” Morganroth said. “No one was even close to getting hurt. There was some physical contact initiated by David Hall, but no punches.”

“What appears to be going on here is David Hall is trying to overblow a very minor confrontation that David Hall caused in an effort to pressure Dan Gilbert to buy out Hall’s minor shareholder investments in affiliated companies,” Morganroth said.

Todd Flood, Hall’s lawyer, responded by saying “This is a Monday surprise to me.  David Hall did what was appropriate. He’s the victim of a crime and he took the matter to the police.”

This obviously has zero affect on how Gilbert runs the Cavaliers franchise, but since he is such a massive public figure in Cleveland, it obviously deserves mentioning. What’s interesting is that if Randy Lerner or Larry Dolan (especially Lerner) were involved in a fracas of this kind, people in this town would be up in arms. But since it’s the golden boy Gilbert, it has flown under the radar.

Just something to ponder.

  • Chris M

    But since it’s the golden boy Gilbert, it has flown under the radar.

    I second that, and have absolutely no problem with it.

    Once Lerner actually coordinates the assembly of a team that shows up on Sunday, he can start fights at Bar Mitzvahs also. Until then, no.

    /halfway serious

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Scott

    The real story should be that Gilbert was at a party with T.I.

    Randy Lerner thinks T.I. is something that cornerbacks get flagged for.

  • S-Dub

    This would’ve been a story if it was those two because they would’ve got pounded into the floor and had dreidels (sp) spun of their heads.

    Sorry attempt at some humor.

  • adam

    Dreidels dont usually show up at bar mitzvahs. They are reserved for the Jewish festival of lights known as Hannukah. I wish I had TI and D-wade at my bar mitzvah…

  • Wally

    Fire Dan Gilbert!!!

    And Mike Brown!

    But seriously.. Bar Mitzvah’s are known to be violent rites of passage for participants and attendees.. it’s jewish tradition

    But seriously, Gilbert is the man

  • Harv 21

    Lerner would have rsvp’d to the Bar Mitzvah, then sent Keenan, who would have needed to introduce himself to both the hosts and Lerner’s angry former underling. See, that’s how you avoid public embarrassment. [Good lord, I think I'm channeling Randy]

  • http://serandez.blogspot.com Ezzie

    Also probably isn’t getting much press because Hall sounds more in the wrong, and it doesn’t sound like Gilbert actually did anything other than yell.

  • Boomhauer

    Randy would rather participate in a soccer riot.

  • The Other Tim

    The real story here is that Dan Gilbert held a bar mitzvah where I stayed on my wedding night.

  • Harv 21

    Nah, he was the guest. I feel kinda bad for him. There’s always someone at one of these fancy 300 person events who drinks too much and then feels the need to redress perceived past wrongs. Ask any wedding planner. Usually it’s the ex-wife or husband. So if the dude goes after him in front of all these people, and he tries to walk away, but he eventually yells (or pushes) back, bingo, it’s in the papers.

  • D-Train

    “But since it’s the golden boy Gilbert, it has flown under the radar.”

    don’t like the way you worded that.

    for one, this is an overblown story. the guy got into a screaming/shoving match? it’s not like he pulled out a gun and shot someone.

    i love that our owner doesn’t take any you know what from anyone. some d-bag tried to blackmail him? he didn’t back down. that’s our guy.

    and i would think the “golden boy” has earned maybe a litte big of wiggle room, considering he’s the only sports owner in town that has a freaking clue.

    look, the lerners are good people, they are generous with their money in both charities, and with the team, and what the dolans and mark shapiro have created is very nice, they both pale into comparison to what dan gilbert has done. yes he has lebron james, but he has turned this into a top franchise in the nba. if james signs in 2010, don’t be surprised if we turn out to be the top franchise in the nba in all of your financial/basketball related magazines.

    so yeah, i’m not mad because he stood up to some drunk guy that tried to blackmail him.

  • biff

    Does anyone else wonder whether “David Hall” is just an alias for Paul Silas? Laugh all you want but he’s a prominent figure on the Detroit Bar-Mitzvah circuit.

  • bridgecrosser

    @ TD “But since it’s the golden boy Gilbert, it has flown under the radar”

    Golden Boy is a cheap shot, nothing more than low-brow name-calling. It’s weak and no different and lame – like when others cheap-shotted you on your “”A Moratorium Call on the Cleveland Browns” thread.

    Gilbert worked his way up from nothing, bought the Cavs and built them up. It’s called respect.

    Dan Gilbert’s hobby is power-lifting. I am sure David Hall is lucky somebody kept him from making an ill-advised move against Gilbert.

    Gilbert needs no protection from shady agents, crazy businessmen or lazy journalists, least alone a cheap-shotting blogger. He’ll be fine.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Denny

    @ bridge – I don’t think “Golden Boy” is a cheap shot.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CEp6-MAFbCY

  • bridgecrosser

    I forgot about that old reference. Didn’t Golden Boy end up dying? Hey I’m a huge Oscar De La Hoya fan so sometime Golden Boy can be a good name.