May 21, 2013

Braylon Edwards’ Unspecified Injury Explained

edwards

If you’ve been following the news out of Berea (what little there is) you probably already know about Phil Dawson’s participation and Jamal Lewis’ return to the field. Mary Kay Cabot reported today that Browns’ WR Braylon Edwards was held out of practice yesterday because he was recovering from an ‘unspecified injury’.  The injury, while not believed to be serious, was enough to keep him on the stationary bike for organized activities.  Cabot’s piece included the story about Edwards taking batting practice with the Tribe, and also included a quote from a source close to Edwards that “his major-league dalliance has nothing to do with his absence from the football field.” That is true. But careful followers of WFNY know where he was injured.

Go back and read through Scott’s Tuesday piece on the star receiver and find this tucked away in the comments:

So he may be in great mental condition BUT 2 weeks ago he was at EMH in Avon playing some basketball and twisted his ankle, it may just be a precaution but he was then at the movie theater on Saturday in an air cast when I saw him so yet another little injury for him….. He was a really nice dude but it just pissed me off he twisted his ankle in a pickup game when we are paying him millions, wear ankle braces or something!!

The Browns refused to comment on this or any injury, but sources close to the team describe it as accurate.

(UPDATE: We’ve spoken with John, who was working out at the EMH when Edwards was injured. He stands by his story that Edwards was injured playing basketball and later was seen with a “gray air-cast boot” on his ankle.)

It doesn’t sound like a serious injury, and certainly there is plenty of time for Braylon to heal. But it doesn’t surprise us that the Browns would be interested in keeping this injury quiet. Fans may not be too excited to hear that Braylon was hurt playing around again.

Is there a provision in Braylon’s contract in regards to basketball? Should there be? You may remember Braylon’s participation in Curtis Granderson’s charity basketball event.

Look, Braylon is a world class athlete and you don’t really want to stop him from participating in athletic events, but there is such a thing as taking precautions. What fans want to see is Braylon making good decisions this season. That and a better catch to drop ratio.

(Photo courtesy the OBR)

  • Clown Baby

    Sometimes I wish he’d get a skydiving “injury.”

  • JK

    It’d be tough to trade him if that happend.

  • ELOCK

    Simply put, this guy is not an NFL-caliber receiver. As much as people rag on him, I get the sense that most still think he can be an elite receiver; he cannot.

    I don’t care if he is a world-class athlete, the primary skill for his position simply doesn’t come naturally to him.

    Just like an athlete who is not very fast can do very little to improve his speed, a player who can’t catch a football naturally is never going to have that skill.

    It would be like a guy who ran a 4.9 all of a sudden running a 4.4.

    This guy is not a big-time, elite receiver, and he never will be.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Denny

    @ ELOCK – I thought the primary skill for his position is wearing gaudy coats and sunglasses. That seems to come quite naturally to him.

  • Clown Baby

    @Denny and ELOCK

    You guys are only saying this because he went to UM.

  • eshaw

    funny story cause in all seriousness… I actually know the dudes he was playin ball against, so I found out about this last week, and apparently Braylon isnt too bad on the court

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Scott

    six-feet plus… uber athletic… and he will not hesitate to throw it down on dana jacobson.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Denny

    He will, however, hesitate to stop Buzz Bissinger from ripping Leitch a new one.

  • mendy

    ah, the excellent and always timely reporting of WFNY. love it

  • Regis

    @Clown Baby – lol

  • S-Dub

    To me it’s not a big deal because he could’ve twisted it stepping off the curb or working out to prepare for the season, it happens. And if he would’ve broke it playing hoops we probably would’ve been able to gain some money back from him and he would’ve been out so it would’ve been like we traded him. What some people wanted right?

  • Jeff

    I completely disagree with Elock saying he is not a NFL caliber WR. That statement is ludicrous. He may never be an elite top 5 guy, but not many are. And I disagree you cannot be taught to hang onto the ball. You can’t teach speed for the most part, but you can make a guy carry a ball with him everywhere he goes, to the shower, the toilet, to bed, in the car, etc. Those techniques have been done before to help people hang onto the ball. I think a lot of the early season struggles from the team in general got in his head and he stopped focusing as much as he should.

    I am not a Braylon apologist. But I am also not an Ohio State honk who goes out of his way to rag on Braylon because he went to Michigan. I could care less what school he went to. I just want him to catch balls from Quinn and give us some offense.

  • Jim

    Confirmed on the ankle injury. My son’s friend was playing in the game when he got hurt at EMH. What a douche……

  • mgbode

    cedric benson played bball tonight in a charity event in austin….he went down with what looked like a really gnarly injury…

    ended up just walking it off, but cmon guys..you are paid too much cash to be risking yourselves like the local YMCA guys

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Denny

    @ jeff – I’d venture a guess and say about 5 guys a year are top 5 caliber.

    I’m an “Ohio State honk”. Braylon is on the Browns now – I can take my “tOSU blinders” off, or whatever you want to call it. And you know what? Even then, I can tell he’s just not that good. Not going out of my way, it’s pretty obvious to me.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Scott

    Back of the envelope… Fitzgerald, Wayne, A Johnson, Moss and Steve Smith?

  • http://www.jrosen.wordpress.com Jacob Rosen

    Calvin Johnson, Jennings, Boldin?

  • MrCleaveland

    He’s getting smarter. At least he wasn’t playing barefoot.

  • Scotty

    @ 4 and 5, hahaha, as i sit here just rolling in laughter at my computer

  • Greg

    Maybe if he had a real QB like Carson Palmer throwing to him he would be an elite WR!

  • Pingback: The Week In Review | WaitingForNextYear

  • Pingback: Braylon Edwards Fails Physical, Placed on Non-Football Injury List | WaitingForNextYear

  • Pingback: Is Braylon’s “Injury” Actually a Holdout? | WaitingForNextYear