May 22, 2013

Anderson Varejao: The Second-Best Player on the NBA’s Second-Best Team?

Anderson Varejao HawksAnderson Varejao’s career has changed at such an incredible rate in the past 10 months, and the following question now seems to be a very valid one for the 27-year-old Brazilian. In fact, he currently leads the Eastern Conference’s best team in rebounding while also leading the NBA in the controversial statistic of plus/minus. The former 2004 second-round draft pick by the Orlando Magic has seen his minutes per game go up in each of the past five seasons and is having a phenomenal start to his 2009-2010 season.

Just under one year ago however, Cleveland Cavaliers fans were starting to wonder what his true value and worth were to this franchise for the future. Look back at this article by Rick from last March, and you will start to see where some of the controversy arrived. Should the team consider giving a long-term contract to a role player whose best value arises when he comes off the bench and creates a hectic atmosphere for opposing offenses? The answer in the end was an astounding yes, as Varejao received an extraordinary $50 million deal over the course of the next six seasons.

When the deal was announced, criticism was rampant as the team essentially locked up their available cap space for the next two years with this known quantity of a reserve. Many people argued that since he had never averaged more than nine points per game in an entire season, there was no way he could be worth upwards of $8 million a year. The haters raged on and on about how the signing was one of the first blemishes of the Danny Ferry era where it seemed he bid against himself for a player with limited long-term potential.

But how do you all think of that deal now? How could Andy not be worth every single penny of massive contract thus far? As of right now, he could possibly be one of the most underrated players in the entire NBA because of all of the things he does that are not recorded in the traditional box score. With the season about halfway completed, I am now here to submit to you loyal WFNY readers that in all actuality, Anderson Varejao is Cleveland’s indispensable second-best player. Here are my three main reasons why this is true:

Plus/Minus
The evidence here is alarming. Anderson holds the best mark in the entire association in terms of plus/minus by a fairly convincing margin, including an astonishing .304 plus rating per minute. What this means is that when he is on the court, the Cavs win by an average of 0.3 points per minute when he is on the court. When you average that out along with his 30.2 minutes per game, Varejao puts up about an average in the +/- category of 9.02 per night. That is just unreal in terms of productivity when you consider the argument that brought plus/minus to the forefront of NBA statistics.

Before the season started, Henry Abbott over at TrueHoop analyzed the numbers behind the two sides to try and understand why Oklahoma City’s Kevin Durant’s +/- was so low. The back-and-forth nature of the attacks on both sides tried to either show that his a) the statistics were trying to tell us something or that b)the numbers simply overlooked his contribution to the team. This year however, you have to credit coach Mike Brown for his usage of Anderson off the bench as a key to winning ball games. As he told ESPN’s Chris Sheridan, “I play Hickson with Shaq because I want to play Andy the whole game, but I can’t play him the whole game. So I decided to start J.J. because in the first eight minutes of the game, we’re not going to win or lose it…. It’s just at the start of the game it makes more sense for me and for the team to have someone else, and not play Andy 38-39 minutes a game. But his value to us with whoever’s on the floor is off the charts.”

Fewer Mistakes
Cleveland basketball sage Brian Windhorst had an awesome article the other day about how Anderson changed his game from “horizontal” to “vertical.” The examples that Windhorst use state that when he first entered the league, he was known as a one-skill asset to the Cavaliers. His contributions relied upon drawing charges from opponents and he was the best in the business at this, leading the NBA by a hefty margin back in 2006-2007. This style of play however, led to an incredible rate of fouls, turnovers and overall mistakes by the young Brazilian. His foul play was so well-documented that 82games.com even had an entire article about how much higher his value would be if he avoided such extreme foul trouble. Winhorst noted that these poor signs led Varejao to change his style of defense where instead of flying down on the floor, he is standing straight and tall in order to avoid the foul.

Flash forward to January 2010 where Anderson is posting a career-best 1.34 turnovers per 48 minutes as well as 0.63 combined blocks and steals per personal foul. He ranks fourth in the NBA in that first statistics among the 208 players that have registered at least 600 minutes of action this season. Compare that radical improvement with his numbers from his first four seasons in the league where he averaged 1.76 turnovers and 6.33 fouls per 48 minutes. Back then, it was an extreme risk every time he touched the court because he was so mistake-prone despite his abilities as a defensive nuisance. In contrast, this season is clearly his finest in terms of limiting his mistakes and focusing solely on his skill sets.

Higher Efficiency
One of the main reason’s Rick article is a keeper is because of the sentimental value it holds for me as it was only the second time my name ever appeared on this wonderful site. In my few comments, I argued there that his agent certainly could make the argument that his production is up there with the top players in the NBA. That is certainly true yet again here in 09-10 when you look at the detailed rate statistics: Varejao is one of only 18 players in the league who average 30+ minutes per game to average 13.3 points and 12.9 rebounds per 48 minutes of play. That puts him once again in such elite company as Dwight Howard, Tim Duncan and Carlos Boozer while Varejao actually has the third-lowest-per-48-minute usage rating of all the players in this category.

As noted on the FS Ohio broadcast Monday night against Golden State, Varejao has recorded at least four rebounds in all 38 of his contests this season. Taking a deeper look at his advanced game log courtesy of Basketball-Reference.com, Andy’s defensive rating (estimated points allowed per 100 possessions) has only exceeded 110 on six occasions all season. Additionally, his offensive rating has only slipped under 90 six times as well, proving that he is as consistent as they come from the power forward position. Another feature of his game is that this season, he is taking 80.3% of his shots from within 10 feet, the highest percentage of his past four years according to HoopData.com. Clearly, since he is not known as a prolific outside shooter, he has adjusted his game to going towards the basket instead of relying upon his inconsistent jumper.

Overall Findings
The heavy statistics can start to tell a bit of the story concerning Varejao’s contributions to these Cleveland Cavaliers. After all of these numbers and figures, it is very hard to ignore the argument he is the second-best player on the team that holds the second-best percentage record in the NBA. Certainly, Mo Williams has his edge as a secondary offensive option to LBJ and Shaq was brought into town to stop the Howard’s/Gasol’s/Bynum’s of the world, but Andy is the one constant force alongside LeBron in Cleveland. Over the past four seasons, the team is only 20-18 when he doesn’t play but a much better 171-77 (.690) when he does. He improved his game drastically after receiving his massive new contract, a rarity for most professional athletes who don’t have to work as hard for their next big payday. As Cleveland fans, we can now only hope that Anderson “Wild Thing” Varejao will be here long into the future alongside that certain #23.

(The photo above is via David Liam Kyle/NBAE via Getty Images)

  • http://shakesthesnowglobe.blogspot.com EZ

    Just a general site note, you might want to change the color of the hyperlinks in the “Indians version” of the site. It’s really hard to pick out the dark blue from the black.

  • http://www.twitter.com/osuadamr Adam

    great analysis!

    but we are the best team in the NBA cuz we smashed the lakers at home

  • Jay

    Andy is in fact the second best player on the BEST team in the NBA. (I think the Cavs get the nod because we beat the Lakers – screw percentage points!) He’s playing out of his mind right now and if he doesn’t win the NBA’s 6th Man Award (assuming his play continues throughout the season) it will be a travesty. Finally I have one jersey in the closet that’s not a total waste….well two if you count Lebron, but that’s a given.

  • Tron

    My one and only problem with Andy has always been his strength. He goes to the basket weak, and gets the ball knocked out of his hands. A good number of his trips to the free throw line could be and 1s if he went strong and dunked the ball, as opposed to trying to lay it in. Other than that, he’s been doing a phenominal job, and his contract definately looks right on.

  • Roosevelt

    Good article. As far as his contract, though, a player has two different values; to his team, and on the open market. Varejao is priceless to the Cavs, but he’s not worth 50 mil on the open market.

    Also, this shows the importance of consistency, something that Ferry and Brown preach and practice. With Varejao, they identified a keeper early, even when he was inconsistent. This allowed Varejao to grow into and adapt his role alongside Lebron, even when the rest of the rotation has slowly changed around them.

  • Mike

    Yeah, not sure I can agree with that whole “second best team” part. Right now, today, the Cavs are the best team in the league, regardless of record.

    That being said, you could argue that Andy has been the most consistent Cavalier this season, even moreso than LeBron James. When he’s on the court, he’s always doing “Andy things,” putting pressure on the opposing team both offensively with his cuts to the basket and defensively with the way he harasses pick-and-roll and crowds the lane from the help side.

    While I remain concerned about the state of the Cavalier bigs next season, as long as Andy is here the front line is going to be solid. In a league where useless 7-footers are always overpaid (ahem, DeSagana Diop is making $21M over the next 3 years), Varejao represents a solid bargain, if not a steal.

    But here’s a question: if the Raptors demanded Varejao in a Bosh trade, would you do it?

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Scott

    Awesome work, Jacob.

  • Roosevelt

    @Mike: I’d carry him on my shoulders to Toronto.

  • humboldt

    nice work Jacob, really well done

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Andrew

    @Jay: Varejao has no shot at winning 6th man. 0%. It’s a 2 man race between Jamal Crawford and Carl Landry, and as long as Crawford keeps playing the way he has been lately, I think it’s his award to lose.

    But I do agree with Jacob’s overall point that Varejao is the Cavaliers’ 2nd most valuable player. I’m not sure if I would use the word “best” though. I would still consider Mo Williams the Cavs’ 2nd best player. But Andy is definitely more valuable to the team than Mo.

  • Jay

    @ Andrew – Honestly, I think it’s Crawford’s to lose. Andy had too many ‘not-in-the-stat-book’ stats. What are those…intangibles? I agree with your comment, I’m just too much of an Andy fan. Rose-colored glasses (& bunkers :) ) and all.

    @ Mike – I would cry for about 3 hours, and then do a backflip. Andy gives you energy, hustle, good defense, and a little scoring. Bosh gives you 24pts 11reb & 2-3 blocks a night. I’d pull that trigger.

  • Dave

    A key factor in Andy’s game: More than any other player, he keeps playing when LeBron has gone into “take over the game” mode. He understands that by moving, he’s at least distracting the defense and giving LeBron another option besides “count 20 seconds and heave”, as well as positioning himself to get any rebounds that may pop out (one of the many weaknesses of the LeBron-on-5 offense is that defenders invariably have superior rebounding position).

    Where Andy’s game really came alive, I think, was playing for the Brazil national team. If you watch his play in that, he’s doing a lot of things he hadn’t been doing for the Cavs (including shooting from longer range). He comes back, and drops a 3-ball when no one was expecting it, has more driving and post moves, and is a much more varied player than the Andy we saw 3 years ago.

  • rorschach

    “But here’s a question: if the Raptors demanded Varejao in a Bosh trade, would you do it?”

    An astounding NO. Bosh is overhyped, overvalued, and overrated. Who on the Raptors are better for being around him ? No one. If anything they get worse (Turkalu, anyone remember that guy ?).

  • Swig

    I basically agree with everyone above.

    If Varejao was being relied upon for points on the offensive side I think his value would be diminished (which was the haters main point). On this team he is a monster.

    The reason you’d pull the Bosh trade is because Bosh has a more complete game. Although, I wouldd be sad to see him go and feel a bit bad because it would hurt Andy’s career.

  • Abe

    Tremendous writing and analysis Jacob! This should be mandatory reading for all NBA beat writers and ESPN/TNT analysts to change their preconceived biases about Andy. Great stuff!

  • Mike

    @Andrew – There’s no question that Anderson Varejao is the Cavs’ second-best player. While Mo is a useful tool on this team, he has nowhere near the impact that Varejao has on a nightly basis.

    There are dozens of players who could match Mo’s production given his role in the offense and his opportunities. There are very few players in the league who could give the Cavs what they get from Varejao given his role and opportunities. He also helps on the defensive end, something that Mo has struggled with, particularly lately.

  • 5KMD

    Love Andy, I really do. But it would be interesting to see him without Lebron. Comparing him to Duncan, Boozer, and Howard is fine but those guys are first options to score. I still think Andy would have a tough time doing that consistently.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Andrew

    @Mike: Sure there’s question. I question it. I think Mo is a better basketball player. AV is just a more valuable player. Those are key differences.

  • Ohrly

    Andy makes LeBron better. He’s also one of the most entertaining players in basketball, and brings 100% effort every night. It has been great to see his offense improve so much this year. I hope the Cavs never let him go.

  • Harv 21

    To me, the highest risk factor about giving him all that money was that his skill set- high energy defensive intensity and moving without the ball- depends on max effort brought evey night. And you just don’t know if a guy will be the same that way after he gets big money. If the money gets good to him and he starts relaxing on defense and doesn’t have even one reliable way to score, you’re stuck with a useless, untradeable drain on your cap. But he’s bringing it harder than ever. I do still dream he’ll spend one summer practicing one shot other than “wide open reverse layup.”

  • http://ibleedorange.wordpress.com Paul

    Andy still can’t shoot a jumper. If you think the NBA is going to give this award to another just high energy guy your wrong. Let’s give that award to players that actually have shooting abilities and score for their team.

  • Matt#2

    rorschach and WFNY,
    I would love to see a whole post dedicated to “what happened to Turkey-glue?”
    And anything Turkey-glue is related to the Cavs, so far as I’m concerned, considering how he murdered them last year.

  • Matt

    Nicely done, Jacob…the plus-minus is tricky, since the argument can always be made that players like Andy who come off the bench benefit from playing against the other team’s bench, etc…but you did very well to also include FG%, shot location, defensive rating, etc…other things to note: his FT% is at a career high 65%, his block % is at a career high 2.7%, his TO% is the lowest since his rookie year, and despite his usage being at a career low, his offensive rating is a career high: usage, essentially, is a player’s percent of FGA, FTA, and TOV..this means that despite actually taking less shots (coupled with the lower TO%), Andy is scoring just as much and helping the team just as much on offense…

  • Maximus

    Awesome analysis. I do agree that Anderson is the second most valuable player to the Cavs for one simple reason that is so fundamental to all sports, yet so under-appreciated: the guy HUSTLES. The reason Varejao is in every play, is because unlike so many other players who take themselves out of the play if they miss a shot, Andy is always around the basket when the shot goes up. His pesky defense irritates the hell out of guys like Garnett and Sheed, in the same manner as Zaza Pachullia, Luis Scola, or any other foreign player whose not athletic enough to reject shots, but smart enough to impact them. He’s a great teammate for Lebron. You can see it in their chemistry on the court. Andy is the only player quick enough to set a (decent) high screen – Shaq is too slow, and Z simply fades to the side for the open J. Futhermore, Andy gets the majority of his points off of feeds from LeBron when he cuts to the basket. While everyone else seems to stand around the watch LeBron, Andy is the one guy whose continuously moving, trying to impact the stagnation.

    What’s more, apart from improving his defensive scheme, he’s improved his ability to finish at the basket and his free throw percentage. He’s not a strong finisher, but for a guy whose ’6’11, he’s crafty at getting tough looks around the rim to fall. If he can shoot 65% from the charity stripe, I’ll take that any day with all that he brings to the table. When all is said and done, one thing is for certain – if the Cavs are in a close game, there are 2 guys guaranteed to be on the floor at the end: LeBron and Andy. Watch tape of any of the Cavs’ close games over the last 5 years, and the footage doesn’t lie, he’s always on the court in crunch time. I don’t see why people would think that 50 mil over 6 years is a bad contract for a guy who has such a value for his team, never mind what the NBA FA market “values.” I believe that there would be many teams salivating to have a player like Andy on their squad, regardless of his unorthodox style.

    All this being said, however…Andy for Bosh? How about Andy, JJ, and Mo for Bosh and Turkgolu? Oh yeah, I’d do that.

    It doesn’t hurt to dream:

    Delonte/Gibson (still a scrub)
    LeBron/Parker
    Hedo/Moon/Jawad
    Bosh/Powe/D-Jack
    Shaq/Z

    Talk about a size advantage there. No one, not Atlanta, not Orlando, not Boston, not even LA would stand a chance against that lineup.

  • Pingback: Links To The Present: January 13th, 2010 « Cavs: The Blog

  • http://www.msblsim.com boogeyman

    Varejao isn’t the second best player on the Cavaliers it’s either Delonte West or Mo Williams which is why Ferry needs to go out and get an Antwan Jamison. Varejao is the personification of sixth man. Just my opinion.

  • Eric

    That fact that Andy is the second best player on the Cavs explains perfectly why the team hasn’t won a championship.

  • Joe the Bummer

    If Anderson Verejao is the 2nd best player on the CAVs, what a sorry state this team is in. Varejao is a journeyman-garbage type player worth no more than $2.5 million a year. I’ll give him this, he is the MOST OVERPAID player in the NBA – hands down.

    Best team in the league over the World Champion Lakers?? Give me a friggin’ break. Stop dreaming. The CAVs must get by either Atlanta, Orlando, or Boston before even thinking about the Lakers.

    Keep hope alive. Peace out. Sanity rules.

  • suuz

    @ roosevelt
    I would disagreee and say Andy is worth the $50 Million. It is hard to say this with a straight face, but that isn’t a big dollar number in NBA terms. When you look at the list of PFs who make equal to or more than Andy you will see that his salary is justified. Only players under “rookie contracts” make less. I have posted numerous times on this topic. The salary is structured so he “could” make up to $50 million over 6 years, but his CAP number is around $7 million in the oh so important LBJ free agent year. Andy will have earned it if he reaches the full value of this contract. Here’s a look at non rookie contract Forwards in the NBA: In 2009-10 season Andy makes $6.3 mil , KG makes $19 mil, Josh SMith ATL makes $10.8 mil, Tyson CHandler $12 mil, Boris Diaw $9 mil, Brad miller $12 mil, Eric Dampier $12.1 mil, Dirk $19.8 mil, Nene $10.5 mil, Kenyon Martin $15.9 mil, Tayshaun Prince $10.3M, Charlie Villanueva. $6.5 mil, Andris Biedrins GS $9 mil, Vladimr Radmanovic $6.5 mil, Shane Battier $6.9 mil, Troy Murphy $11 mil, Mike Dunleavy $9.7 mil, Marcus Camby $9.2 mil, Chris Kaman $10.4 mil, Andrew Bynum $12.5 mil, Pao Gasol $16.5 mil, Zach Randolph $16 mil, Jermaine O’Neal $23 mil, Udonis Haslem $7.1 mil, Andrew Bogut $10 mil, Dan Gadzuric $6.5 mil, Mark Blount $8 mil, Brian Cardinal $6.8 mil, Tony Battie $6.6 mil, Bobby Simmons $11.2 mil, Emeka Okafur $10.8 mil, Eddy Curry $10.5 mil, LARRY HUGHES $13.7 mil, Darko Milicic $7.5 mil, Al Harrington $10 mil, David Lee $7 mil, Etan Thomas $7.9 mil, Nick Collison $6.3 mil, Rashard Lewis $18 mil, Dwight Howard $15 mil, Vince Carter $16.1 mil, Elton Brand $14,9 mil, Samuel Dalembert $12 mil, Amare Stoudemire $16.4 mil, Joel Pryzbilla $6.9 mil, Kenny Thomas $8.8 mil, Andres Nocioni $7.5 mil, Tim Duncan $22.2 mil, Chris Bosh $15.8 mil, Hedo Turkoglu $9 mil, Andrei Kirilinko $16.5 mil, Carlos Boozer $12.3 mil, Mehmet Okur $9 mil, Paul Milsap $7.7 mil, Antwan Jamieson $12.2 mil.

    After seeing this list I think I like Andy’s contract and would take him over more than half of these guys before comparing their contracts.

  • suuz

    @ Joe The Bummer. Apparently you don’t follow basketball much or you’d know Andy isn’t anywhere near the most over paid player in the league. One of the O’Neals (Shaq or Jermaine) are far more deserving of that title.

  • Joe the Bummer

    @Suuz

    At least Shaq and /or Jermaine was worth that type of money at one point in their careers.

    But hey…Danny Ferry is known for overpaying guys – and yes Shaq is overpaid…as is Jermaine O’Neal. And so is Varejao.

  • suuz

    Joe I agree with your idea that professional athletes/entertainers are overpaid but Varejao in comparison to other veteran NBA players is no where near overpaid. I provided back-up to this statement in response to roosevelt a few posts up. What is your back-up for your statement that he is overpaid in comparison to other veteran NBA players?

  • Joe the Bummer

    Suuz… you asked me

    <>

    Name one player on that list who Varejao tops statistically (at $8 mil a year). Also, Varejao makes $8+ mil per year not $6 mil as you stated. (six years $50 million) Varejao has no mid-range jumper, nor any offensive game…all of his points come off free throws and tip-ins. That my friend is a garbage man. He averages 8 pts and 8 rbs per game. Such mediocre performance is not close to being worth $8 million a year – more like 2.5 mil a year.

  • http://www.twitter.com/osuadamr adam

    BEST TEAM IN THE NBA

    boot rocking it out with stats… too bad it cant win u a fantasy football title brother!