June 18, 2013

“The Decision” May Have Cost LeBron James In More Ways Than One

By now we’re all beginning get an idea of what LeBron’s “Decision” has cost him. For all the opportunity he supposedly gained, he has lost just as much in terms of brand, likability, and public goodwill from NBA fans across the nation.

People have said LeBron gained an opportunity to win multiple Championships, which is funny because I thought he had that opportunity to do the same in Cleveland. Perhaps it will prove to have been harder to do in Cleveland than in Miami, but as LeBron himself said that fateful night “One thing you can’t control is you never know.” For now, that opportunity is rooted in speculation until they prove that 3 great players (Wade, LeBron, Bosh) surrounded by a couple average players (Mario Chalmers, Mike Miller, and I suppose Udonis Haslem) and a whole bunch of below average players (everyone else on the team) can win a title.

Another opportunity he gained was the chance to play with his friends. Again, this is funny because I thought he had that in Cleveland. For the last couple years all of us in Cleveland have immensely enjoyed watching those Cavs teams interact together, and it was LeBron who was the ring leader of all that fun. It sure looked like a bunch of friends playing basketball together, anyway, but I guess now he gets to play with members of his “fam” like Udonis Haslem. Because, you know, it just wouldn’t have felt right to LeBron if Haslem “wasn’t apart (sic) of this”.

Maybe I’m just a jilted lover, but yes, I’m still bitter over The Decision…both the figurative one and the literal one. And with all due respect to ESPN, who continues to be the self-imposed moral authority of sports in telling us all that we’re wrong for being mad at LeBron for any of this, I’m going to instead process all of this at my own pace. I’ll move on when I’m good and ready, and I don’t ESPN’s help with this. I got it.

While I continue to ponder what LeBron’s senseless handling of the decision may or may not have cost him in PR and good will, not to mention what the literal Decision cost Cleveland and the Cavaliers, it never occurred to me all the other ways The Decision could be assigned cost.

That is, until I read a fascinating article in the Stamford Advocate which talks very specifically about the added cost LeBron incurred in order to carry out his silly little TV show. The Advocate’s Neil Vigdor writes,

Producers of the July 8 prime-time special hired 21 police officers to work security, each of them earning $60 an hour for an average of eight hours, according to Lt. Kraig Gray, who was in charge of the operation.

So who gets stuck with the bill of at least $10,000?

“I believe it was LeBron’s people,” Gray said.

Don’t look to ESPN.

“ESPN was not involved with the local police,” said Nate Smeltz, a spokesman for the Bristol-based sports entertainment giant.

Another two officers were called in to do security on an overtime basis, a cost that Gray said will come out of department’s budget and be borne by taxpayers. They also averaged about eight hours at the $60 rate, according to Gray, putting the cost at just less than $1,000.

That’s really only the “tip of the iceberg”, though. This was just for security at the Boys & Girls Club in Greenwich, where Vigdor says officers mostly had to stand there in the heat and listen to the irate (presumably) New York fans shout obscenities and vulgarities. Think of all the additional security required across NE Ohio that was required in the wake of this Decision.

Security was posted outside LeBron’s house in Bath Township, presumably paid for by LeBron. But who paid for the police officials who had to guard the poor LeBron mural in downtown Cleveland? Nike? LeBron? The Cavaliers? Then you consider the extra police presence that was extended throughout Cleveland as a precaution against any violence. And then there were the extra body guards LeBron had with him in Cleveland on that last day in Ohio.

It all begins to add up, and you just kind of wonder what that cost was and if it was really all worth this. Such drama, such pain, such anger and feelings of betrayal. Numerous NBA writers across the country have displayed an uneasy feeling toward LeBron James and the way this whole situation unfolded. Many fans are left feeling once more like the NBA pulled a fast one on them.

We knew when free agency started that LeBron’s Decision, whatever it might be, would send shock waves and reverberations throughout the league, but I never anticipated anything quite like what we saw. Most of what I’ve heard and read from ESPN (the unofficial LeBron James PR team) has said this is all overblown and will die down as soon as LeBron wins a Championship with his BFFs in Miami. They might be right. Heck, they probably are. People have short memories in this country and we winning solves most problems in the NBA. For now, though, I continue to just marvel at the destruction of LeBron’s legacy in the present time and shake my head at how unnecessary all of this really was.

_____________________________________

Image Source: (John Kuntz / The Plain Dealer)

  • jcb

    Didn’t think that highly of ESPN before all this, but the way they set this thing up, and all there commentary both before and after “The Decision” has really turned me off. They have lost the support of this internet user. That will show them!

  • john

    I go from thinking about getting League Pass so I can watch the Heat games, to telling myself that the NBA is as fake as pro wrestling. This whole LeBron thing is horrible.

  • http://www.twitter.com/azv321 Amin

    Yeah, I haven’t clicked on ESPN links for the past few weeks, except Cavs: The Blog. I’ve replaced all my bookmarks of theirs with Yahoo Sports. It’s all regurgitated AP anyway.

  • jvt

    Yep, same here! I haven’t been to ESPN’s website since, and have only turned on their station to watch the British Open. I use to drink that XXX Vitamin Water all the time but refuse to buy it now. I won’t buy Nike products at this point either. I am so pissed that the water I buy at Food Lion has the boys and girls clubs logo on the water (i guess they donate proceeds) so I ended up paying a dollar extra for Aquafina!

    I know this is pathetic…oh well! GO CLEVELAND!

  • St. McDuck

    I really get the feeling that there’s now just two teams in the NBA: Miami, and everyone else.
    Nobody I’ve talked to in person likes LeBron anymore (and this is in Los Angeles, where some people at least respected him as “almost as good as Kobe”).
    I do hope he fails now. I hope the NBA does have a lockout next season and it takes the rest of LeBro’s career for the league to recover.
    Maybe the 5-year old Kobe-in-training growing up right now in Cleveland can learn from this, because the 25-year old LeBro certainly won’t.

  • stin4u

    Still kicking a dead horse here…but I suppose time heals all wounds. 2 weeks and counting with no ESPN for myself and I’m not missing it at all yet.

  • g

    that “average” player Mike Miller would be the best player on your very below average Cavs. Dont be bitter that Ohio cant compete with South Beach. GO HEAT!

  • MattyFos

    On “Outside the Lines” I hears Scoop Jackson or whatever that dude’s name is say the he agrees with Jesse Jackson. HA. That’s the last time I watched ESPN. How can they put trash like that on their airways? It’s just race baiting and it’s an absurd accusation.

  • jcb

    I only know one Heat fan, even he is pissed/disgusted/embarrassed with this whole thing.

    Has anyone tried that Great Lakes Quitness?? I live in Chi, and was going to have one of my boys hold on to a sixer for me, was disappointed to see it wasn’t available in bottles.

  • MattyFos

    http://www.harrisinteractive.com/NewsRoom/HarrisPolls/tabid/447/mid/1508/articleId/441/ctl/ReadCustom%20Default/Default.aspx

    Harris Poll “Favorite Sports Star”
    Number 6 Slipped from 3rd last year, behind Tiger and Jordan, to 6th this year behind, Kobe/Tiger, Derek Jeter, Brett Favre, and Peyton Manning.
    That’s pretty sad when the “New and Improved” Tiger/ Kobe “Colorado” Bryant, and Brett “retire/unretire” Favre are viewed favorably over number 6.

  • MattyFos

    @g
    whoa,The Cavs roster is anything but below average. Jamison and Mo are proven very good players. Andy Varejoa (even though I hate him) is a solid performer, better than anybody outside of “those three” you have. JJ Hickson is ready to have a breakout year, and I would go out on a limb and say put up about 16 pts and 8 reb a game.
    But, g, I don’t expect you to know that. You Miami fans are a fickle bunch. You are probably only just interested in the Heat. You seem like a ring chaser, just like “Number 6″.

    Thanks for stopping by. It’s always a nice to see other teams’ fans on here. It’s a good reminder that Cleveland fans know about sports, and can form an intelligent opinion on sports…

  • Stinkfist

    Andrew, the cops at the big mural, the cops at his mansion, and the cops as his body guards would still have been necessary even if made his decision to leave in a respectful fashion. Don’t kid yourself there.
    Cops having to stand in the heat listening to profanity? Oh, heaven forbid! They’re getting paid… and not by taxpayers… by LeBron
    Come on WFNY, you’re better than this

  • Jim

    @G: If you’re going to comment, at least have some facts at your disposal. Miller wasn’t even the best player on the woeful Washington Wizards last year.

    That being said, people faulting Lebron for going to the Heat (as opposed to the way he actually did it which to me is the real issue) are either wilfully ignorant or still real upset. Lebron, Wade, and Bosh are going to be unreal together. Right now Hollinger has them pegged for 61 wins. The main obstacle for that team will be skilled big men (Howard basically: Bynum is a bum), and quick point guards which give every team issues (Rose, Rondo, Paul). Right now I think only Orlando is on par in the east, due in part to Howard, with Chicago right behind (I refuse to believe the aging Celtics can make another incredible run).

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Andrew

    Better than what?

  • Tim

    @13- whoa, 61 wins!? That would be an incredible season since only 1 team won 61 games last year. Which team was that again?

    Agreed on Mike Miller, though. He might do well in Miami with all the attention away from him, but he’s not as good as Jamison or Mo Williams.

  • Stinkfist

    Than this article.

    You also failed to include a pretty important line from your reference. It was about how most of these cops depend on the private hirings to supplement their 36 hour work weeks.
    “I know a lot of guys around here depend on it to live,” Bonney said. “If it wasn’t for side jobs, half the [officers] here would leave, probably. It’s not taxpayer money.”

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Andrew

    I don’t see your point at all. I think the point of this article went way over your head. The money the cops make is such a small part of this article. It’s more about what LeBron’s decision all cost him. Some of it’s money, but much more of it is in other ways.

    Sorry you’re offended by this article, though.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Andrew

    Also, feel free to email me with your concerns with this article. I really don’t understand why you have such a problem with it.

  • http://www.adapterdesign.com adapterdesign

    There was a $3.5 million dollar difference between the ad revenue generated and what was donated to Boys and Girls Clubs…. I don’t really think he lost anything monetarily.

  • Stinkfist

    Its not over my head. At all. I dont think 10-20 grand out of LeBron’s pocket for his own private security adds up anywhere near the amount of damage he contributed to himself PR-wise. Its peanuts to him (unless, of course, he still doesnt think he did any damage).

    You tried to make the cops the victims here because they had to endure high temperatures and unruly fans, yet crap like that is what they rely on for income.

    And even if he decided to leave in a respectful fashion the way Craig illustrated the other day, there would still be a patrol car or two parked right by that mural. He still would have hired security for his palace and for himself. Its not like live TV had anything to do with that. Live TV affected the 21 cops who got paid by LeBron, not the other stuff you mentioned

  • http://gooddoctorzeus.blogspot.com DocZeus

    I’m sorry when did Mike Miller become more than an average role player? His numbers have been steadily slipping for 4 seasons now.

    And he HASN’T ever played meaningful basketball beyond April…

    Robert Horry, he is not.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Andrew

    Well, with all due respect, all those points you just raised have nothing to do with this article.

    All that happened was I read this article about how LeBron paid for the security at The Decision, and thought it was interesting and decided to pass it along to the readers. Never once did I even remotely feel any pity for the cops themselves. Not when I read it, nor when I wrote this. So no, I didn’t try to make the cops the victim here because that thought never even occurred to me. Nor did I ever think that the amount LeBron spent on them was more than his PR hit. The whole point of this is that it’s all combined. It’s all cost.

    As for whether security would have been there regardless, it probably would, but it’s still a cost. If you go to a restaurant and order a hamburger, it costs you money whether you eat it or not. Same here. It’s just a cost I hadn’t thought about this particular issue before and thought it was interesting.

    There was no agenda here as far as defending security or anything ridiculous like that. If you read it that way, I’m sorry and you’re right, I can and should do better.

    I’m not sure if everyone read it that way, but I hope not, because that’s so far from the point of this article. I was just bringing to light something I found interesting, and then question whether when you combine all these costs, from the security to the PR hits to the public good will, was worth it for LeBron.

  • MrCleaveland

    I used to love Pardon the Interruption until Wilbon offered an angry defense of Jesse Jackson’s slave/plantation comments, and Bob Ryan, who was filling in for Kornheiser, meekly nodded and didn’t challenge him. Ever since that moment, I cannot watch that show.

  • Dave

    Whoa Stinkfist, I do think you missed Andrew’s point. It wasn’t all about the jack and I didn’t get the feeling he was trying to make the cops out as victims at all. My take on the post was there is a lot of fallout from this in addition to all of the money #6 spent on security. It appears to me he was just trying to put some monetary value on the announcement. To say he was ripping cops for making cash on the side is not what I got from it at all.

  • MrCleaveland

    Also, all those security costs are chump change for The Global Icon.

  • Jim

    @15: 61 wins would be incredible. That’s why I listed it. Hollinger’s wins predictor had the Cavs in the high 50′s to low 60′s for this past season I might add. Cavs were able to win that many because they had Lebron and a solid team around him. Miami will have Lebron and one other super star and another all-star next to him. I’d expect the same results wins wise for #6 this season.

  • Tim

    I get that it would be a good year, but in the days after LeBron signed with Miami, I was hearing about how some simulations had the Heat winning more than 82 games (really well-made simulators, clearly), and 61 just seems underwhelming for a team that’s supposed to be so much better than the Cavs from the last few years.

  • Stinkfist

    Here’s what I took the wrong way from your description right below the reference. In your words…
    “This was just for security at the Boys & Girls Club in Greenwich, where Vigdor says officers mostly had to stand there in the heat and listen to the irate (presumably) New York fans shout obscenities and vulgarities”
    Since you said you meant nothing by what you said, 50% of my frusteration was apparantly misplaced. The other half is alloted to the notion that 10-20 grand makes any difference whatsoever in him caring about his decsion, and the irrelevance the manner of his announcemnt (live or press-release) had on the duties of certain officers.
    Good chat buddy

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com Andrew

    No worries. I’m serious when I say if people misinterpret my points, it’s a sign I need to be better, which is something I always strive to do. I’ll learn a lesson from this situation. The reason I included the line you quoted was because I was already being somewhat snarky in the first few paragraphs, so I decided to include that info about what the cops were doing that I got from the Advocate article.

  • Stinkfist

    I did think it was funny though how that same article said that Dave Matthews hired about 50 cops for a charity concert. Thankfully the put it in terms I can understand, otherwise, I couldn’t even have imagined 21 cops.

  • T

    Definitely a jilted lover. Seriously, love the site and visit it multiple times per day, but cost of police to a bagillionaire? C’mon man. He leaves the city and “Oh, yeah…well let’s talk about how much your security cost…”. Lame

  • saggy

    i think it is awesome that people are referring to him as #6.

    It reminds me of disgraced former New York Governor, Eliott Spitzer. He is now known as “Client #9,” which was his code name with the expensive call girls he was eventually caught with.

    Ha Ha Ha – #6.

  • The Other Tim

    In reading LeBron’s tweet I hear, “Thank God Haslem’s on board, if we don’t win this year I won’t have to listen to folks saying, ‘Wade won with Haslem but couldn’t win with LeBron’”

  • Chris

    A million championships won’t fully repair LeBron’s legacy.

    Jordan owns his championships. Sure, he had Pippen and Grant, but those rings are HIS.

    If he had one only one in Cleveland for his whole career, it would have been his championship, delivered to a starving town and saving his franchise.

    Every championship he wins in Miami will be shared between Wade, LeBron, and Bosh. I don’t know that basketball has ever seen something quite like that, and I don’t know what it means for LeBron, but I know it’s not the same as winning and being a hometown hero.

  • cninja

    god, can we just go back to talking about how much we suck at football and baseball?

  • hans

    @34, actually the Indians are on a rip right now and the Browns look to be margin contenders for the playoffs this year, so…

    @23, they needed Rob Ryan from the Browns instead. That wouldn’t have a meek nod. He may have eaten him

  • Barry Mahoganue

    My favorite nickname for LeBron these days is the one Reghi mentioned on KNR today: The Chosen One-Third.

  • Bo Hopkin

    MY crystal ball tell me,the Heats will have 3yrs to win a champion,after the third yrs,they will trade LBJ to the West conf.Even though all 3 of the sign a 6yrs deal but they could leave after the 4 yrs,unless the salary cap is sky high,the Heat will not have enough money to resign all 3 of the them.Since the Heats is DWade team they def will resign him between Bosh and LBJ u def higher trade value of LBJ,and the Heats will not be stupid to LBJ to the East cof,so he will ship to the Clippers for Blake Griffin.

  • Roosevelt

    Here’s an Iconoclastic point: Lebron is not that rich. For all the talk about being a billionaire, he makes, what? 40 mil a year? He’s in a tax bracket that pays 45% or so to Uncle Sam.

    And while most NBA guys pay a posse to be hairdressers and garage maintainers, Lebron pays his guys to be highfalutin’ marketing executives. LRMR Marketing, for example, has fancy offices, employees, and private jet time. They have two (2) clients. Commission on Chris Paul’s and Jonny Flynn’s endorsements does not pay for private jets. Lebron does.

    Add up the cost of countless luxury cars, countless parties, and while I don’t think he’ll have trouble buying groceries, he’s not headed for Buffet territory, or even Jordan territory. Apparently, Jordan gained something from being the most thoroughly unlikable person in the history of the human race.

  • MattyFos

    Actually the highest tax bracket is 35%, for now. It will be 39.6% after the new year.

    Both of those figures are Federal tax, and since Florida has no state income tax, those numbers are cemented. I’m sure wherever he chooses to live will have a local tax. Canton is 2%, But bigger cities tend to have higher taxes. Plus, Florida sales taxes vary between 6.25%-7%.
    Florida has some of the highest property taxes in the nation. So, Roosevelt, you are pretty close to the 45% estimation. I’d say it’s closer to 50% though. Especially after he just bought a 50 million dollar house.

  • Andy

    Dude has the right to play for whatever team he wants. Its his life and man has freedoms u dipshit.