May 24, 2013

The Best Browns Since 1999 – Special Teams

I figured I’d end the week on a happier note than some of the other categories. No better way to do that than with some love for Phil Dawson.

Punter probably couldn’t have been much closer.  The Browns have undoubtedly had some pretty good (and oft-used) punters since 1999.  Dave Zastudil probably got the nod because he is also a local boy.  Gardocki will forever be known as the first “Punter-As-Team-MVP” punchline for the “new” Browns.

Dennis Northcutt could certainly make a claim based on stats, but he was never going to overcome the impossibly popular Josh Cribbs in a fan poll.  And really, you can’t say Cribbs isn’t deserving of the honor.

Kick returner wasn’t close and shouldn’t have been close.

Stay tuned for next week when we start to get into defense and eventually quarterback.

Offensive Line - Left Tackle | Left Guard | Center | Right Guard | Right Tackle

Pass Catchers - Wide Receivers | Tight Ends

Runners - Running Backs | Fullbacks

Special Teams

  • mgbode

    not surprising at PR.  disappointing, but not surprising.  I also give Northcutt extra credit to get a ST spot based on the most amazing onside recovery I have ever seen (the one where Phil lofted the ball to the weak side over the first line of opponents and Northcutt tracked it down tip-toeing on the sideline and made the recovery)

  • Garry_Owen

    0.7% Cundiff.  Seriously?

  • Max

    Hey, even Mondale got some votes in ’84

  • Garry_Owen

    Adjust my one thumb up for inflation.

  • Foghorn Leghorn

    at Tennessee.

  • @37crookshankave

    This is so disappointing. Cribbs just isnt a very good punt returner, GREAT AMAZING kick returner but if you look his touchdowns come almost all on Kick returns, and he has a lot of trouble catching punts its just not his specialty. I know it seems like kick returns and punt returns are the same but they are not. Northcutt should have been recognized as our best punt returner, he was really really good at it esp the one year he exploded and won us multiple games. I dont know how Chris Gardocki lost either, but maybe he wasnt as good as I remember but his problem was that he went to the steelers afterwards and for that…F ‘em!

    lastly whoever didnt vote Dawson should lose all their other votes shame on those people or person!

  • sealedhuman

    According to research, everyone likes more cash…