May 26, 2013

Grossi: Brad McCoy Comments Sealed Son Colt’s Fate

It appears that comments by Colt McCoy’s father, Brad, have sealed the fate of his son with regard to the player’s future with the Cleveland Browns.

Though the Browns had hoped to land quarterback Brandon Weeden with the 37th-overall pick, the team was in fact ready to replace Colt McCoy, writes ESPNCleveland’s Tony Grossi, after McCoy’s father went to the media following his son’s concussion against the Pittsburgh Steelers on December 8, 2011.

“I’ve been told that McCoy’s fate as a former starter was sealed when his father sounded off about the club’s handling of his concussion,” writes Grossi. “The comments did not drive the pursuit of a new quarterback, but I believe they contributed to McCoy’s demise.”

In 2011, McCoy regressed mightily from his rookie campaign, completing only 57 percent of his passes at 5.9 yards per attempt. He would miss the final three games of the season following the concussion, sustained within a game wherein he would ultimately return to the playing field, leading to a whirlwind of criticism and league attention.

Grossi’s report also confirms WFNY’s intial belief that the Browns were targeting Baylor wide receiver Kendall Wright with the 22nd-overall selection in the recent draft, but opted to go with Weeden following the selection of Wright by the Tennessee Titans at No. 20.

[Related: Browns Backing in to Wide Receiver Improvement]

  • Mark

    “I’ve been told that McCoy’s fate as a former starter was sealed when his father sounded off about the club’s handling of his concussion,” writes Grossi. “The comments did not drive the pursuit of a new quarterback, but I believe they contributed to McCoy’s demise.”

    I dont understand this. His second sentence contradicts his first. How could Colt’s fate be sealed if the comments didn’t drive the pursuit of a new QB?

  • http://FantasyTrophies.com/ FantasyTrophies

    Mark, I caught that too.  Again, a story that “journalists” conjure up to create controversy.  McCoy has an average arm.  That, not his father, led to his demise. 

  • Moohead

    Grossi’s fate as a former journalist was sealed when he sounded off by irresponsibly tweeting. His comments did not drive the PD’s pursuit of a new writer, but I believe they contributed to Grossi’s demise.

  • Natedawg86

    I disagreed with putting McCoy back in the game, but why would his dad say anything to the media?  Should have known better than that.  That is almost the same as the golden rule in football.  If your child is hurt on the field, stay in the stands.

  • REEPJP

    Like x 100

    BTW, you aren’t the Moohead that used to stream the games at Moohead Radio are you?  If so, thank you a million from someone who used to live out of the area.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/2JF7JF4QHKPD7DX2RMXLUQ7LUU AJH

    As soon as Colt’s father opened his mouth, I said he was a goner!…

  • Max

    Isn’t Colt McCoy (and by extension, Brad) from a very small town in Texas? 

     Isn’t Brad McCoy some kind of motivational speaker or something? I’ll bet Colt starting for 4 years and setting records at Texas was good for business. I’ll bet him being a starter in the NFL was good for business. Seems to me like anytime something happens that is bad for business, ERRR, I mean something bad happens to Colt, there’s good ol’ Dad out there in the media, getting names in headlines.Is he a Father or an opportunist? Is he afraid of having to go back to the dim lights of a small town in Texas? Hard for me to tell.

  • BuckeyeDawg

    Yeah, I’m sure his performance had nothing to do with it.  Colt seems like a good kid with a lot of heart…and I was/am pulling for him…but let’s not pretend we’re dealing with Johhny Unitas here. 

    Another day, another manufactured or rehashed drama in Cleveland sports.  Even as an avid Cleveland sports fan, it gets old after a while…

  • 216in614

    If the regime thought Colt could be the man it makes no difference what his father said to the media. “He’s been told” by who? That doesn’t mean a thing unless we have a creditable source…

  • MrCleaveland

    I cannot understand why McCoy’s father is being criticized or why people think his criticism of the Browns is such a big deal.

    He’s a FATHER who saw his son:

    1) Brutalized by a vicious, dirty hit by a vicious, dirty player, and

    2) Put back in the game when he shouldn’t have been by an overwhelmed, clueless bumbler of a coach.

    If that had ever happened to my son, I’d scream about it too and I wouldn’t care who did or didn’t like it.

    McCoy’s father is not the villain here.

  • Harv 21

    now that’s a sweet counterpunch

  • Harv 21

    now that’s a sweet counterpunch

  • Ryan P. Goldchains

    if anyone knows anything about comments sealing your fate, it’s Grossi!

  • PNR

     My 3-year old son will NEVER play organized football.  I think that’s the type of decision that real FATHERS make.

  • ChadF

    So if something crappy to you happened at work and your Dad came in and not only blasted your current employer for the incident, but commented about it and publicized it to the local and national media, you’re saying that should have no bearing with how your company might handle your employment moving forward?

    I understand this is professional sports and it is entertainment, but think of how many athletes there are in professional sports whose parents DON’T make fools of themselves.  Brady McCoy, Gloria James and even Archie Manning to some extent need to shut their mouth and let their children make millions of dollars for playing a game.  

  • ChadF

    Brad*

  • Wgfsh

    He may mean that it was the straw that broke the camel’s back.  The thing that tipped it over with the relatively poor play getting it to to the edge.

    It’s still contradictory, though.

  • MrCleaveland

     ”Something crappy”?????

    What happened to McCoy was a lot worse than “something crappy.”

    Sheesh!

  • Harv 21

    agree.

    There’s also a direct relationship between the performance of a player and a team’s tolerance for parental meddling. Maybe Holmgren was annoyed that Mary Kay reported it while he was trying to circle the wagons around Shurmur, but if Colt was playing like a franchise QB they would have made nicey-nice with pops. Various forms of this stuff has surely happened in Denver with Elway’s dad/coach, in Indy and NY with Archie Manning, and with the Cavs and Gloria. Experienced NFL guys don’t make personnel decisions based upon a parent’s emotional reaction. Suspect Grossi is now trying to get a little edgy and noticed in his Second Act.

  • Satch

     That is assuming there is a demise in the Browns eyes. Just more bullshit reporting by Tony Grossi making story’s where there aren’t any. Mary Kay Gossip called Brad McCoy, then led him with questions then blew his answers out of proportion. It is haw you manufacture a story. Propaganda Journalism 101.

  • Natedawg86

    yeah but will your 10 year old son play organized football?

  • dwhit110

    I’m very anti-Grossi, and maybe I’m in the minority, but I’ve actually felt like he’s been a lot better since leaving the PD (not as toxically negative). Perhaps the change was good for him.

  • TwelveInchFinch

    Im sure you’d have no problems remaining quiet if you watched a professional football team allow your child to be put in a position to suffer serious brain damage

  • TwelveInchFinch

    Living in fear is the sign of a responsible parent?  News to me

  • porckchopexpress

    Something tells me that if Colt had completed 67% of his passes for 27 TD’s and 12 picks, Brad McCoy’s words would not have meant as much.
    That being said, Colt’s a grown man, if my boss made a stupid decision that got me hurt I wouldn’t want my dad showing up cussing people out.
    That being said part deux,  I still think this was one of the most piss poor Maury Povich journalism jobs on the part of Mary Kay, and I haven’t read a thing she writes since.  What the hell is she calling up a players dad when he got hurt?  Does she do that for every player?  When Tony Pashos was out there on 1 wheel probably morphined out of his mind trying to play did Mary Kay call papa Pashos to see how he feels about it?  Just the lowest form of headline hunting in my opinion.

  • Humboldt

    Oh come on, why do people use this ‘unwritten rule’ nonsense? There was a systematic failure that led to mccoy’s son being placed in a dangerous situation. Speaking up prompted the nfl to change its protocol, which will protect players in the future. For this to have become an issue with browns leadership is absurd

  • Vindictive_Pat

    It was me… I sent Grossi a tweet on his secret account, @BS_Leader.  I was like, “Man, there isn’t enough NEWS going on right now… let’s drum some up!”

  • Humboldt

    This is simply ridiculous ad hominem

  • TwelveInchFinch

    Crap like this only contributes to the idea that Cleveland is a hopeless sports town.  Players see how someone like Colt McCoy has been jerked around and never been given a true chance to succeed despite doing all the right things as a professional, who in their right mind would want to come here?  Garbage team management and even worse “reporting”

  • https://twitter.com/jimkanicki jimkanicki

    >>>.. PD’s pursuit of a new writer ..>>>

    if only.  instead we got more of the second string writers.

  • Humboldt

    Well said mr cle. Silly season continues just in a different dress

  • http://twitter.com/oribiasi oribiasi

    Depressing, party of one, your table is ready.

  • BrownsFanSF

    I was a Colt supporter, but I think “average” is being nice.  He just simply didn’t have an NFL arm

  • Mike E

     McCoy did all of the right things as a professional except be good enough at QB.  It’s not his dad that sealed his fate, it was his play on the field.

  • Khaotic_bliss

    it’s the browns, who cares!!!

  • Khaotic_bliss

    Colt was a choker anyway…Big games in Texas and he blew them…He belongs with the browns, a bunch of chokers…

  • Dawgpound4Life

    Colt was never given a real chance as a starter. Colt’s receiving corps minus Cribbs cant catch the damn ball. Neither could they run correct pass routes. The offensive line aside from Joe Thomas was terrible.  Our biggest offensive weapon is our kicker and has been for the past three years.  Fine, we drafted what appears to be a high quality running back, but there is still no legitimate playmaker in the receiver position.  Another questionable draft that leaves most brown fans scratching their heads.  Ownership is more concerend with how their soccer team is doing then their football team and Holmgren and company appear to be footballs version of the keystone cops. We will be lucky to be a 500 football team. But, current management of this franchise will view that as their superbowl. There is no immediate need to win.  The Lerner family have been thanked enough by the cleveland faithful for bringing the browns back.  It is now time to stop running this franchise like an expansion team.  Consistent positive results are needed now.  As a die-hard browns fan, I am demanding a team that isn’t considered to be a laughing stock. 

  • Ossie Vitt

    “I’ve been told that McCoy’s fate as a former starter was sealed when his father sounded off about the club’s handling of his concussion,” writes Grossi. “The comments did not drive the pursuit of a new quarterback, but I believe they contributed to McCoy’s demise.”

    Really, Tony?/? Do you really think a billion+ organization cares about what McCoys father said? How childish are you? What must you think of your readers?

    I despair.

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    I would tend to disagree with the title of this story but then I remember all those press conferences where both The Big Ego and Heckert reacted to being questioned and reconsidered.  I can’t believe the Browns would be that petty or could they?

  • BenRM

    I completely agree w/ Grossi here and have been saying it for some time.

  • BenRM

    i agree w/ you, actually.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/HV2SIFP7KDJJAXRJERUIDRNNKY Ken

    just trade the poor kid…….im a father and if iseen my son hurt and being mishandle in a dangerous situation i would speak out also …..why are you dumb browns fans trying to defend a worthless FRONT OFFICE and  coach who didnt SEE THE HIT!!!!! GIVE ME A BREAK YOU LIAR{ SHURMUR} the browns offense is a joke not Colt mccoy,but no, lets replace the qb again.why cant shurmur come out and take a lot of the blame for crappy clock management,play calling was a joke ……shurmur is the one that has no upside …HES A DAM JOKE

  • Jamieimel

    I would say that is not true at all. If here could be a starting QB  then he still would be despite what his father said.

  • mgbode

    obviously a troll, but:

    2009 – undefeated and got to nat’l champ game.  injured in game.
    2008 – lost to TxTech (only loss), but beat Oklahoma and Ohio State.

    Rivalry games
    3-1 vs. Oklahoma
    2-2 vs. A&M (lost Fr&So years.  Won Jr.&Sr years)

    Bowl games
    3-0 (3-1 if you count the Nat’l Champ game when he was knocked out in 1st Q)

    Call him a failure in the NFL if you will, but his college resume is pretty bulletproof.

  • mgbode

    “HES A DAM JOKE”

    Welcome, for the next hour, I will be your dam guide. Please note that this is a hydro-electric plant and is dangerous, so do not wander off the dam tour.  There will be time to take plenty of dam pictures.  Before we begin does anyone have any dam questions?

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    I don’t think McCoy is as bad as many people think he just ended up in a perfect storm of a mess with the Browns.  He isn’t alone though look at the long line of failed QBs this team has had since ’99.  Those same people should think about that before they heap all the problems on one guy.

  • Gary

     ok getting hurt in the national championship game constitutes “blowing” a big game right???? Colt had the record for the most wins as a college quarterback when he left college.

  • Max

    no, not at all.  An Ad hominem attack is when you attack the messenger’s character to discredit their argument.  The argument here was Grossi’s, not Brad McCoy’s.  I am not trying to disprove anything Grossi said. In fact, the main point of this article is :

    “I’ve been told that McCoy’s fate as a former starter was sealed when his father sounded off about the club’s handling of his concussion,” writes Grossi. “The comments did not drive the pursuit of a new quarterback, but I believe they contributed to McCoy’s demise.”Which means that Grossi is the one writing that HE believes it is true. I simply pointed out that the elder McCoy seemed a little too involved in his son’s public life, and it always seemed a bit “Manchurian Candidate-ish” to me.  Colt’s about to get traded or benched, and all of a sudden though, here’s Brad McCoy’s name in the paper. I just don’t think that is a coincidence, is all.Nice try using Latin though. Maybe next time

  • mgbode

    it’s not like any of the QBs who failed here went off to have great success though (outside a small stint with Garcia on the Eagles.  but, AJ Feeley had a small successful stint on the Eagles too)

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    Well they better have solved it this year or else!  ;-)