May 18, 2013

Shake-up Coming to the Tribe Rotation After Another Dismal Start

The bottom of the seventh inning included a conversation between Underwood and Manning which eventually made its way around to “sometimes the best trade you can make is not to make one.” Um, not in this case boys.

You had to wonder how the team would react last night. Not just because of the trade deadline that came and went with nary a change in the clubhouse, but also because of the embarrassment of the Minnesota series. I was hoping we might see a little fire. Then I saw Lowe was the starting pitcher, and I realized that the fire may just be coming off the bats of the Royals.

Derek Lowe is either in a severe slump, or it is the end of the line. Let us let some of the Tribe’s scribes describe the scene from twitter-

I could post a hundred tweets, but you get the idea. The stats just don’t lie. Derek Lowe over his last 3 starts: 15.88 ERA (20 ER/11.1 IP). Lowe over his last 13 starts: 8.28 ERA (61 ER/66.1 IP) with 97 H, 28 BB, 28 K. He just isn’t getting the job done.

But that doesn’t stop the Indians from handing him the ball every five days.

So Lowe gets lit up early again, and the Tribe sends in Josh Tomlin to pitch. Manny Acta had told reporters before the game that he may have to address the rotation with the front office sometime that evening. I’d say Tomlin’s appearance as long relief is a good indicator that he is no longer in Acta’s rotation, and you have to wonder about Lowe’s position as well.

After the game was over Manny Acta would name Corey Kluber the starter for Thursday night, taking Tomlin’s place.

To his credit, Derek Lowe didn’t make excuses- “It’s been live BP for the last two months. No excuses. Can’t say I got a bad break here or there. That would be a lie.” It was honest, but listening to the audio you can’t help but imagine his confidence is gone.

The offense made Luke Hochevar a winner for the first time since July 5th. They managed 8 hits, and Hochevar gave away at least one out by not covering first in time, leading to at least one of the Indians’ runs.

Then there was Santana’s blunder in the 8th. After Escobar’s throw went sailing over the first baseman’s head, Santana crossed first and turned toward second before rounding back around to the first baseline and WALKING toward the base. He was tagged out because you can’t overrun first and turn towards second. You have to turn away from the infield or else you are in play. Thanks Carlos. Good effort.

  • erchoov

    The sad part is Antonetti and Shapiro refuse to admit they’re wrong about the Ubaldo trade and will continue to push the silly idea that this team can compete next year. Instead of freeing up some money for next year and infusing some young talent into the system, we’ll get garbage at next year’s deadline for Choo, Perez, Jimenez and probably Masterson. Our front office is the biggest joke in sports.

  • http://www.cinpleweb.com/ stin4u

    What is even MORE sad is that the Dolan’s wont fire either one of them. I hope this team returns to an empty stadium. I would feel bad for the players, but they’ll continue to get paid.

  • typo

    Then they’ll threaten to move, and blame us fans for not supporting the team.

  • erchoov

    It’s a huge cycle of awfulness. The most frustrating thing is that no one is held accountable for terrible moves. Instead of getting fired, Shapiro gets promoted. I don’t even expect an owner or the Dolan’s to spend a ton of money. I do expect them to make moves that make sense. The Jimenez trade was terrible all the way around. Spending $20 mill on Sizemore, Fausto, Lowe, and Kotchman was a disgrace. The only thing I really fault Dolan for was making is public news that we had to trade Victor and Lee right at the deadline instead of maximizing their trade value and not holding anyone in the front office accountable for terrible trades, FA singings, and drafts over the last decade.

  • nj0

    I think Derek Lowe’s 2012 would be a good case study for all those anti-stats people.

  • mgbode

    even with the arbitration guys, we’ll likely be in the low $40mil range for next year. we’ve shown that our budget is in the mid $60mil range to start the season. that leaves ~$20mil.

    who would we have traded to free up more $$ for next season?

    I agree that I would have liked to see some young prospects brought in. We need more in our system.

  • Chuckr

    Columbus Indians? I sure hope not, but smell the threats coming.

  • simond

    should be an exciting off season with money to spend…

    hafner, sizemore, lowe and kotchman are coming off the books