May 23, 2013

Awaiting the Fallout of the Off-Field Fracas

The week leading up to the start of the NFL regular season has provided Cleveland with a stark juxtaposition in terms of words, delivery and ultimate reaction. As a handful of our nation’s best orators take to the stage in Charlotte, North Carolina 1 , amidst the pomp and circumstance and Springsteen, those sequestered in Cleveland, Ohio have felt words, albeit more regionalized, reverberate though the airwaves and jump off of the pages.

Indians closer Chris Perez kicked things off by providing his latest fact-based hay-maker, responding to a reporter in search for the quotable goldmine that has been the non-filtered right-hander, attacking the economics of the game which he plays while managing to two-hand toss both his general manager and ownership team into the fire as their lakefront Rome continues to burn.

“Different owners,” said Perez of the difference between the small-market Indians and small-market Detroit Tigers.  “It comes down to that. They (the Tigers) are spending money. He (Ilitch) wants to win. Even when the economy was down (in Detroit), he spent money. He’s got a team to show for it. You get what you pay for in baseball. Sometimes you don’t. But most of the time you do.”

Just days later, we find ourselves dealing with the passing of the most polarizing man in the history of Cleveland sports; Art Modell’s passing provided such a wide range of emotion and analysis that it’s more than a day later and people are still waxing on about what his legacy means to them and them alone.

But just like the national scale of the various conventions that have taken place leading into November, it will be the next steps which are discussed and speculated upon. The fallout. The butterfly effects. What will the Indians front office do with their arbitration-eligible All-Star closer? As they continue to say that their primary goal is to build a better team in what is their contention window, would they trade a player away for being honest? A bit of a distraction, sure, but has anyone been able to debate anything that was said earlier this week? The team states that any penance will be handled internally, but if the closer is shopped this off-season, it is a sure sign that pride is the chief currency on the corner of Carnegie and Ontario 2 .

A trade of Perez could net the team a prospect or two, but with a front office that has a reputation for taking less than full asking price in the trade market, would this team honestly be better off, talent wise, without their All-Star closer? After all, all of this (non) wheeling and dealing is all about fielding the best team possible.

Following the passing of his father, David Modell gave no mention of Art’s legacy in Cleveland. Portrayed as a hero by select national types and most Baltimorians, the majority of Modell-based reports contained quotes which were rooted in the man’s decision to move the Cleveland Browns to Baltimore.

“I leave my heart and part of my soul in Cleveland,” Modell said during the move. ”But frankly, it came down to a simple proposition: I had no choice.”

“I have a great legacy, tarnished somewhat by the move,” Modell later said in 1999. “The politicians and the bureaucrats saw fit to cover their own rear ends by blaming it on me.”

But where does this leave the new Cleveland Browns? The version that filled Municipal Stadium on countless Sundays won a Vince Lombardi trophy while wearing that dreadful purple and black and double-homicide red 3  doing so under one of our own in Ozzie Newsome. The NFL could levy league-wide moment of silence, or even flags flown shy of the summit, but the city of Cleveland had a three-year moment when no football was being played — no fans congregated, no whistles were blown, no cochlea-rattling music was played before or during the actual games.

Some can say that the Browns should “do the right thing” by honoring the recently deceased contributor. Is setting the paying fans up for nationwide mockery the “right thing?” As I mentioned on Twitter Thursday morning, the instant reaction of many outside of Cleveland was to set the sites on the wounded. “Congratulations, Cleveland,” said one national writer, doing so in a completely unsolicited manner. It’s then in this same breath where Clevelandersare told to “get over it.” If a mandatory moment of silence is in fact cast upon the 32 teams, which stadium do you think will be the focus of FOX Sports and ESPN? The one that was neglected by the son of the man to whom we would be paying respect 4 .

The end goal is winning: both presidential candidates, Chris Perez and the Cleveland Browns. All of the ancillary, needle-moving public relation items are merely the cost of doing business. In the world of Point As and Point Bs, it’s often the path taken that gets the most attention. The next 48 hours for the Browns coupled with the next four months for the Indians will undoubtedly be highly scrutinized. Often times, one cannot win regardless of their decisions. All of the involved parties, however, have to hope that these are one of those rare occasions.

(Photo: Chuck Crow/PD)

___________________________________

  1. This is by no means a political admission, it just fits in the time frame being used. Save it. [back]
  2. Especially considering that the team continues to refute all Forbes reports on their actual currency [back]
  3. Yes, I know this alleged incident happened one night after the actual Super Bowl. Poetic license. [back]
  4. And don’t even get me started on the Hall of Fame potential [back]

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    The organization will be in a difficult position if something league wide is done. Personally I hope this isn’t the case because it’ll allow them a way out in order to avoid the fans who will be captured by the cameras and replayed at nauseum. Everyone knows the moment of silence won’t be silent. For the most part I skipped yesterday’s obituary here because I knew what to expect I guess I’ll just skip ahead to the actual kick off on Sunday, if necessary.

    Of course all of this could have been lessened had this organization achieved some sort of winning over the last 14 seasons. That’s the bottom line no matter how unfortunate.

  • http://www.cinpleweb.com/ stin4u

    I, for one, cannot wait till Perez is suspended. Now that the team is out of it, and he’s aimed his verbal chainsaw at the organization instead of the fans, the front office will be hard pressed not to sit him down and “teach him a lesson”. I feel like the fallout from that move should be significant since he wasn’t reprimanded for spouting off about the fans but once he targets his bosses, well, that’s another story. Awful.

  • nj0

    “attacking the economics of the game”

    That’s a very generous description of his bush-league rant.

    “a reputation for taking less than full asking price in the trade market”

    Really? Were we supposed to get the Dodgers to throw Matt Kemp in with Carlos Santana for Casey Blake? Maybe demand Ivan Nova and Zach McAllister for Austin Kearns? Oh, but of course… we didn’t hit on all our trades and made some that the fanbase didn’t agree with THUS it means we have a reputation for taking less than full asking price.

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    They should have muzzled him when he ripped the fans instead they all smiled and made excuses. Now that their pit bull turned his attack toward his masters they’ll suspend him? I’m sure that’ll look good across the baseball community and further endear any prospective free agents to this horrible baseball team.

  • nj0

    “If a mandatory moment of silence is in fact cast upon the 32 teams, which stadium do you think will be the focus of FOX Sports and ESPN?”

    Not sure what you mean here. Are you blaming them for being interested? It IS a story. As much as Clevelanders don’t want to admit it, the reaction to such an event would be newsworthy and a thing of interest to most football fans.

    I’ve seen this phenomenon a lot recently – fanbases portraying the sports media reporting and/or investigation of obvious, legitimate stories as some kind of witch hunt. PSU fans (JoPa), OSU fans (TattooGate), Cavs fans (Lebron)… like or not, those are stories. I’m sorry if they may paint you in a bad light, but these are the types of things the media pursues.

  • nj0

    Not just his masters, but his teammates as well.

    I agree completely though. You raise snakes, prepare to get bitten.

    I think what I’m most mad about is how Perez is hurting his own trade value by his constant outbursts. He’ll now be harder to move and we’ll get less for him simply because fewer teams will be interested in a guy who willingly makes himself a headache for ownership.

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    Perez’s antics never sat well with me even when the team was winning. I’ve been consistent unlike the Indians but why should this be any different then all of the other situations they mishandled since the end of last season. You are probably right in that Perez’s mouth isn’t enhancing his tradability but aren’t most closers considered divas anyways? I could forsee teams downgrading him because of it and the happless Indians accepting whatever they can simply to rid themselves of a problem they sat back and encouraged. I wonder if Paul Dolan will need that explained to him too?

  • http://keepstream.com JimEngland

    I would say the statement is accurate, at least in the past few years. The Phillies were able to get Cliffy without providing any top-tier prospects and Jake Westbrook and Austin Kearns were given away for practically nothing.

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    And of course the timing just had to coincide perfectly for week 1 of the season it’s not like it couldn’t have happend a week earlier during the preseason when noone would care or be around right? Modell 3 (the move, a championship and now this), Cleveland 0!

  • BuckeyeDawg

    Nothing good will come from a mandatory moment of silence for Art Modell at Cleveland Browns Stadium. Nothing. It would simply be setting Cleveland up for another embarrassing moment for the national sports media to weave into their “Cleveland sucks” montage.

    If the league tries to mandate it, the Browns just need to say “no thanks”, and deal with whatever repercussions the league would levy for not doing it (if there would even be any).

    Trust me Goodell…you REALLY don’t want to go there. Please don’t try to make us.

  • nj0

    Are you joking? We flipped the corpse of Austin Kearns into a 23-year-old pitching prospect who has shown a few flashes at the ML level and you call that “practically nothing”?

    Westbrook didn’t garner much but that was because he had about $6M coming to him.

    I’ll give you that the Lee deal didn’t pan out and people criticize the value of the prospects they received. But that was a missed trade, not a team fleecing us.

    If anyone can find any reporter or ML front office type saying that the Indians are known around baseball for being easy to swindle, please post it here. That’s very different than fan outrage because some trades haven’t worked out as well as we would have liked.

  • Narm

    Perez was going to get traded either way – I don’t know that it’s fair to say it will simply be from these statements. A team that isn’t good enough to get or keep a lead has little use for a closer. And to Perez’s point, one that will be making north of $7 million next year.

  • woofersus

    It’s not blaming the media for being interested, it’s blaming the NFL for putting the Browns in that position. The moment would not be silent. We all know it would be a moment dedicated to booing and jeering a dead man.

  • mgbode

    your Cliff Lee statement would bear more weight if Philly got anything worthwhile when they flipped him to Seattle.

    Seattle at least thought they got something for him (Smoak), but so far he has panned out for them about as well as LaPorta has for us (both highly thought of prospects when their trades happened).

  • mgbode

    I think Goodell is smart enough to know this and not deflect from what would be meant as an honor (which is exactly what it would do).

    I expect there to be some moments of silence across the league with owners close to Art, but not Cleveland (would have been interested to see if the Rooney’s gave him a moment, but Pitt is in Denver).

  • nj0

    I wasn’t aware of that about the Philly-Seattle trade. Good to know.

  • mgbode

    I agree. And, the one area we seem to have in the pipeline is bullpen guys.

  • http://www.facebook.com/cb.everett.9 CB Everett

    Why try to force a moment of silence and attempt to convince thousands of fans to be “respectful” or “classy?” 1). It won’t work as some will scream or boo or throw feces and then you just set us up for failure and 2). What do we gain from it…good PR? Yeah right. The narrative of “watch CLE fans be classy and respectful” isn’t going to play.

  • mgbode

    this article is old, but it details the trades. the guys Philly got still haven’t panned out:

    http://seamheads.com/2010/07/23/comparing-the-cliff-lee-hauls/

    Gilles is a 23yo in AA who has been injured and struggled.

    JC Ramirez is a 23yo in AAA but has struggled there and was injured this year as well.

    Phillippe Aumont was considered the “prize” in that trade but even that was as the #93 ranked prospect by BA. He is also a 23yo in AAA who has struggled and been injured and no longer shows up on anyones rankings (Phillies consider Ramirez higher in the pipeline by most accounts). He is also a bullpen guy now.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com/ Scott @ WFNY

    Yes, this. Plus, national media appears to like having their cake while simultaneously inhaling it like a wolverine. You can’t, in one breath, tell someone to “get over” something and then send in armies of production crews to broadcast the fallout.

  • http://www.waitingfornextyear.com/ Scott @ WFNY

    Two Cy Young winners, a fourth slap-hitting center fielder and a reserve catcher to show. Don’t come at me with the puddly no sense like Kearns-for-McAllister; hardly franchise-altering.

  • http://twitter.com/GreatestHurley Jason Hurley

    What an odd sample to take on the “less than full asking price” statement. If you were to throw in, say, 2 Cy Young Award winners, I wonder if you could say the Tribe got full asking price or not? Nope…you picked the Casey Blake deal and the Austin Kearns trade. Nice.

  • Harv 21

    Guessing the path of least resistance for the league will be an optional moment of silence, left to the discretion of this week’s home teams. Then, the Browns can confiscate anti-Modell signs at the gate so there’s no video footage for the cliche machines at the networks, but writers nationally can keep their pre-written stories castigating the Browns for not honoring the man who “did so much for Cleveland and brought it the town’s last championship.” Everybody wins, but the video, and they need that video.

    Hey – is there such thing as a Modell jersey? If someone has one of those and some lighter fluid we can be on all the post-game shows this Sunday, most def. How cool would that be. I don’t have time to make a Modell effigy scarecrow. I have an old cardigan sweater and some glasses but I’m not such a good artist. I’m worried it might look like Dick Cheney.

  • nj0

    Prospects not working out are part of baseball.

    That is not the same as “taking less than full asking price in the market”. I’m curious what you’re basing this assessment on.

    If you can find a reporter or front office type saying that the Indians have “a reputation for taking less than full asking price in the trade market”, please let me know.

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    Throw feces c’mon now it’s lunch time besides if the fans of this team haven’t thrown feces in the 14 years since I think it’s safe.

  • nj0

    Not to sound snarky, but why not? I’m being honest here. I don’t see why doing both is wrong or hypocritical.

    A part of media’s job (modern sports media, at least) often boils down to covering people who are being completely unreasonable and/or idiotic.

    Why is it wrong to say, “dudes, don’t be so unreasonable and/or idiotic cause you’ll end up looking classless”? When said dudes decide to be unreasonable and/or idiotic so they end up looking classless, it’s still a story. It still should be reported on, right?

    The prior is just good advice. The latter is their job.

  • mgbode

    you can make that case for the CC deal. I doubt many teams would give up the level of prospects the Brewers did for a 3 month rental (wish we would have chosen better).

    but, the Lee deal felt panic’d at the time and didn’t work out either. hard to say that was a fair price (except that Philly took a similarly poor deal – Seattle got more from a WS-driven TX team. We needed to find that team.)

  • St. McDuck

    I’d like to see the Browns just go about their business on Sunday, no special stuff necessary. He’s dead, let’s move on and try to win a damn game.

  • nj0

    I hear what you’re saying and agree with it, but – and write this off as being semantic if you want – saying that we have a reputation for taking less than full asking price is very, very different than what you’re saying.

    I follow MLB and trade talk rather closely. I have never heard our front office be accused of being push overs or easily fleeced.

    Have we made deals that didn’t pan out? Sure. Have we made deals in haste when patience was probably warranted? Probably. Again, that’s different from said reputation.

  • http://twitter.com/bbo13 B-bo

    “Hey, arsonist! Here’s some matches and some kerosene. I’m just going to set these over here by this pile of oily rags in this wooden shed. Now don’t you go misbehaving, ya hear?” Filming the resulting scene is not “news”. That’s essentially a scripted event.

  • nj0

    Are you suggesting that the media killed Art Modell to film the reaction? Or that they’re forcing a moment of silence to see the reaction?

    How has the media scripted anything here?

  • Hypno_Toad

    Certainly you aren’t referring to Brantley as a “fourth slap-hitting center fielder”.

    Come on now I know you’re upset about the Lee/Sabathia trades like we all are but you’re undervaluing Brantley.

  • mgbode

    i agree. the only time I heard that was in 2009 when a few writers thought we took too little and it was due to a forced firesale. pure speculation, but it seemed (and still seems) true.

  • http://twitter.com/bbo13 B-bo

    Well clearly I’m saying the media concocted an elaborate plot to assassinate Art Modell in the interest of ratings, newspaper sales, and web hits. Of course. My point clearly got through to you.

    Modern sports media (such as Florio over at PFT and the numerous members of the Modell fan club in Bristol…even Grossi appears to be on board) who support the idea of a tribute to Modell in Cleveland know full well that it will be an ugly scene. That means ratings for them and yet another chance to pull out the “Cleveland Montage”, and to wave their fingers from atop their soapboxes at the “classless” Cleveland fan, and to make their Cleveland jokes they love so very much (did you know the river caught fire once??). They KNOW it won’t end well. So push for it beforehand, tell us how we should feel/act, and the when we don’t meet the criteria you lay out for us, criticize. They aren’t covering any “news”. They are taking advantage of a situation. Heck, I’d be willing to bet that several of them already have most of their “story” written/recorded, and are just waiting for footage and photos and quotes to punch it up a bit.

  • nj0

    Sure, there’s the possibility that some media types advocate for a moment of silence in hope that there is a kerfuffle to exploit for ratings.

    I think it’s also possible that they honestly believe the moment calls for some decency and class which the Cleveland fans in the stadium can provide if they decide to do so.

    Honestly, are PFT and ESPN hurting for ratings or stories the first week of the NFL season? Do they really need to manufacture something like that?

    And even if I give you that they are manufacturing a scenario to make us look bad: why in god’s name are we playing into their hands by giving them exactly what they want?

    However the situation comes about, it would be the choice of those people to either show some restraint or behave in a classless way. Regardless of Modell’s past actions and the emotions involved, I refuse to give them a pass and blame the media simply because adults can’t act in a civilized manner for fifteen seconds.

    I’ve read more than a few times the past few days about how Clevelanders are over Modell and how it’s just the media forcing it to be an issue to create a story. If you want me to believe that then have a moment of silence for Art Modell without it being a debacle.

  • http://twitter.com/bbo13 B-bo

    Is Nike hurting for money these days? I doubt it. But is that going to stop them from rolling out $300 LeBrons or $200 Jordans? Unlikely. Ratings and views and readers = cash money, and that’s the bottom line. If that means setting up a city and a fanbase to look bad regarding what is clearly a sensitive and (for many) deeply personal topic, then so be it. Browns fans reacting as they are likely to react–and are entitled to react, quite frankly, if they wish to–isn’t playing into anyone’s hands: it’s having strong feelings about the situation. I’m so very tired of being told by people who don’t understand a situation, who don’t have any emotional stake in it–be it LBJ leaving, or Modell’s death, or the Tribe not selling enough tickets–how people who do should feel. Who the heck are they to tell those concerned how they should feel or react? Particularly when these outsiders’ attitude is to “get over it”, while they poke a stick in our side about it at every opportunity.

    If (when) folks act out in a manner you or anyone else doesn’t approve of this Sunday afternoon, no one will blame the media for the fact that it happened. But the media is and will be exploiting it, and that’s the real shame.

  • nj0

    If you and others want to hate Modell and act out on that (in a legal manner, mind you) — more power to you. I sincerely don’t care all that much. If the crowd makes a spectacle of itself on Sunday, I’ll shake my head and feel kind of sick that we as a city can get beyond the past, but that’ll be it.

    Just don’t blame the media for poking you with you sticks or talking out of both sides of their mouths or egging you on or whatever. Even if they’re doing it, that’s their right just as much as it’s your right to boo a dead man.

    I don’t have much love for Art either. I’m a born and bred Clevelander and went through all of that too.

    My thing is – own it (which you clearly are). Don’t say it would all go away if it wasn’t for the media (not that you’re saying this). Don’t blame anybody else. Own that hate and accept the consequences. In this case, that means that ESPN and Co. will harp on you and people outside of NEO will think you’re kind of crazy to still be so angry over something that happened rather long ago.

  • jmgatskiejr

    The only thing he deserves credit for is approving the hire of Ozzie to a front office position. Aside from that, bashing is pointless and inappropriate at this time.
    Godspeed.

  • Wheel

    Great column. You’re right about us having our 3 year moment of silence. In the end, the only thing that will ever make us forget Modell, is a winning franchise. Modell’s sins have been exacerbated by the incompetence of the ‘new’ Browns.