Carlos Santana’s Coming Out Party


Carlos-Santana1You probably won’t be surprised when I tell you who the best hitter in the American League has been so far this year. 1

(Oh.  You should probably read the last footnote if you care about how we’re defining “best hitter”.)

Anyway, the best hitter in the American League so far this season has been Miguel Cabrera, and if that surprises you then you should come over here so I can hit you in the nose with my ballpeen hammer.  For the last decade, Cabrera has enjoyed a sustained and consistent excellence that has only been bested  in my lifetime by Albert Pujols’ reign in St. Louis and the late-stage Barry Bonds. 2

Have a look at this table, just for fun:

Cabrera (2004-2012)0.3210.3990.5660.965154151
Pujols (2001-2011)0.3280.4200.6171.037170167
Bonds (1992-2007)0.3110.4760.6631.139200187


That’s just other-worldly dominance, by all three guys.  Let’s just admire that for a second.

Wait.  What is this post about?  Where am I?

Oh, right: Indians and web-logging and whatnot.

Do you know who the second best hitter in the American League has been this year?  I’m guessing you read the title, so you prolly do.  It’s Carlos Santana.

Adjusted for park and league, Santana has been a better hitter than Mark Reynolds and his league-leading 11 HRs and better than James Loney’s absurd .379 batting average and better even (ever-so-slightly better) than Chris Davis and his ridiculous .659 slugging percentage.  Carlos has been that good so far this year.

Let’s take a look at Santana’s career year by year, to see what’s going on.



By the time Carlos reached the majors in the second half of 2010, he was a well-known offensive force, notorious throughout the International League for his combination of patience and power.  And upon his promotion, Santana looked every bit like the real thing, walking in nearly 20% of his plate appearances with an isolated power (ISO-subtract batting average from slugging percentage) above .200,  well above average.

In his first full season in 2011, his approach took some slight steps backwards, as his walk-rate dropped and his strikeouts climbed.  Luckily, his power made up for most of the difference, as he swatted 27 home runs and kept that ISO north of .200.

In 2012, he managed to reduce his strikeouts, but with them went the power.  Through the end of July, Carlos had a Marson-esque .234 batting average, a .388 slugging percentage, and a paltry .154 ISO with only nine home runs.  It was only a late-season surge that kept his numbers from the truly abysmal, but even with that his power still looked sapped.

So what’s different this year?  Not all that much, actually.  His walk-rate (15.5%) is a bit higher than 2011-2012, but not in any outstanding regard—Carlos has always been and probably will always be an excellent master of the strikezone.  His strikeout rate is actually creeping back up to his 2011 levels, but we should know that high strikeout numbers aren’t really all that bad if they come with power, and Carlos has certainly seen a resurgence of that this season.  His .269 ISO is good for fifth in the AL, behind Chris Davis, Mark Reynolds, Jose Bautista and Mitch Moreland (?).  His line drives are right in line with his career average, hovering in the 18% to 20% range.

I know that BABiP column looks a bit scary: for a guy who’s only seen about 27% of his career batted balls fall in for hits, why should it suddenly jump to 37%?  Isn’t this one of those fluky, Tomlin-esque flights that will slowly regress back to his non-excellent mean?

Well, yeah, it could.  But I’ve argued that over Santana’s career he’s been exceptionally unlucky in regards to his batting average on balls in play.  Using this xBABiP calculator, I entered Santana’s career averages and it spit out an expected BABiP of .300 for Carlos, a far cry from .365, sure, but also a lot better than his .260s and .270s he’s labored through for the first three years of his career.

Carlos probably isn’t going to keep up this torrid pace: he’s yet to hit an infield pop-up this season, and nearly 12% of his groundballs are ending in infield hits—neither of those will last to June.  Let’s be sure not confuse him with those three guys I talked about up above.

But he is finally getting some luck to roll his way, after so many years of the opposite.  And this is what he can look like with a little luck and continued development.  He’s a patient, powerful hitter who can be among the best in the game for a non-insignificant stretch of the season, and we have him locked down in Cleveland on a team-friendly contract through at least the 2017 season. 3   You can dream on the kind of late-20s prime Carlos Santana is going to have in an Indians uniform.

In some ways, it’s a shame that his dominance over these first eight-weeks has been buried by the great start of Mark Reynolds and the consistent contributions of Nick Swisher.  It would be easy for Tribe fans to miss what Carlos has been doing, simply because his teammates have been—if not as good—then at least as exciting.

But of course, it’s not a shame at all.  This offense has been the best in baseball this season.  And after five years of Orly Cabreras and Zeke Carreras and Chris Gimenezes, I’ll take that any day.

  1. We’re going to define “best hitter” using a stat called Weighted Runs Created Plus (wRC+).  Basically, we’re park- and league-adjusting a player’s value, using linear weights.  If you like wOBA (and if you don’t you’re a communist), then you should love wRC+. []
  2. I know and you know that Barry Bonds took great big barrels full of steroids.  But let’s go way back in time here.  Let’s go all the way back to 1992, back when Barry Bonds looked more like Sammy Davis Jr. rather than Dwayne Johnson.  From 1992 to the end of his career, guess how many times Barry Bonds had an OPS below 1.000.  Go on, guess.


    Once, in 2006, when it was .999.  One year out of 16, and it was still excellent.  A .999 OPS would currently be good for 10th place in all of baseball—and that’s the worst year of Bond’s 16-year stretch. That guy was freaking amazing. []

  3. Carlos Santana will make less over the life of his five-year contract than ($21 million) than Joe Mauer will make in every year of his deal until 2018 ($23 million per year). []
  • The_Real_Shamrock

    I’d have worded that headline a little differently but other then that sssssssh, don’t tell Santana everyone needs him to keep it going!

  • Garry_Owen

    Whew. I thought this was another “Athlete Alley . . . er, Ally” bait and switch article.

  • mgbode

    when Santana bats, noone needs to understand the infield fly rule

  • mgbode

    Jon, love the breakdown of my favorite Indian player. Yes, he likely will have a downturn at some point for awhile, but he has been absolutely amazing and I wouldn’t find it absurd if we someday do group him near the category of that triumvirate you listed (he obviously has a long, long way to go to even merit such discussions).

  • Garry_Owen

    Somewhere just on the outskirts of New York City, a Pronk-sized tear just crashed to the ground, leaving a crater of sorrow, abandonment, regret, and confusion.

  • Jake Udell

    I wouldn’t be surprised either, especially numbers wise would be right up there with Miggy had he been batting 3rd or 4th in the batting order all year and not missed any games. Also in my eyes hes been better defensively and with the pitching staff this year. Hes truly an all-star now, already I think theirs no way you leave him off considering there will be 2-3 catchers on the team

  • nj0

    Pronk in April 2013- .318/.438/.667
    Pronk in May 2013- .133/.257/.167

  • nj0

    In 3,252 plate appearances over six seasons, Joey Votto has hit 11 infield fly balls.

  • The_Real_Shamrock

    He did qualify it by saying “favorite Indian” though we all know Pronx is his all time most favoritest player ever!

  • JK

    Mostly confusion

  • Vindictive_Pat

    Carlos Santana – Supernatural. Yeah, I did it. I went to the Carlos-Santana-musician well.

  • mgbode

    Pronk has not been my favorite Indian since 2007 though. And Santana has held that flag since he was called up and started mashing (go ahead and check those threads :) ).

    I just like Pronk alot more than the average Indians fan, so I defend him as is just. Much like TJ Ward is not my favorite Brown, but I will defend him as he is much better than most fans think.

    (still upticked the comment as appropriate here 😉 )

  • mgbode

    now, if he could just find where he placed his power (he is amazing though – completely losing his power stroke this year, he still is putting up roughly the same BA & OBP).

  • beeceeinla

    in that case, when it comes to playing defense at 1B, he needs to change his evil ways.

  • NoVA Buckeye

    -Reads 3rd bullet point-

    Well played, Mauer.

  • Jason Hurley

    Pronk in May is also suffering from shoulder issues and is undergoing some tests. So…he’s baaaaaaack.

  • Jason Hurley

    Pronk in May is also suffering from shoulder issues and is undergoing some tests. So…he’s baaaaaaack.

  • Vindictive_Pat

    Feelin’ you, BC

  • Vindictive_Pat

    So glad that we can all stop panicking about Pronk having an MVP season (he says sarcastically). This is the Travis Hafner story, year after year. He starts out hot, he hurts his shoulder or oblique, he misses 80 games or so and is mediocre in between injuries. Did I think he might fall out of that cycle because he’s a Yankee now and it would be fitting? Sure, but I’m glad to see I was being absurd.

  • Harv 21

    “In some ways, it’s a shame that his dominance over these first
    eight-weeks has been buried by the great start of Mark Reynolds and the
    consistent contributions of Nick Swisher.” Actually, there’s probably some causation here. Many of us predicted contributions from a better lineup this year would help Santana relax and not try to yank everything 400 feet.

  • Scott andrews

    I think you kind of minimized the BABiP. .365 is a long way from .300 and a long long way from .278. To me that looks like a guy who will regress significantly soon. I hope not, but it makes me nervous. Makes it seem like he’s had a lot of luck